JOSH PETER

Kaepernick protest lacking something: white male athletes

Josh Peter
USA TODAY Sports
Do players like Tom Brady see eye to eye with Colin Kaepernicks' social protest? It would be nice to know.

Long before Colin Kaepernick took a knee, Tom Brady took a pledge.

In part, the pledge reads, “I will speak up whenever I know discrimination is happening and I will stand up for victims.”

But Brady, who took the pledge last year while participating in a Public Service Announcement targeting racism, has offered no public comment on Kaepernick’s refusal to stand for the national anthem.

Through his silence, the New England Patriots quarterback has underscored a facet of Kaepernick’s ongoing protest that is gaining attention: the limited support of white athletes.

Three women — soccer player Megan Rapinoe and basketball players Jeanette Pohlen and Maggie Lewis — are the only white professional athletes who have knelt during the national anthem as an act of solidarity with Kaepernick, the San Francisco 49ers quarterback.

Doug Baldwin's thoughtful words include a very important call to action

“The struggle for equality continues and athletes across the lines of race have a shared burden to challenge that system," Rev. Jesse Jackson told USA TODAY Sports. “It’s not the burden of blacks and Latinos alone to bear.”

Michael Bennett, a defensive end for the Seattle Seahawks, was even more direct.

"You need a white guy to join the fight,” Bennett, who is African American, told The Seattle Times on Thursday. “The white guy is super important to the fight.

“For people to really see social injustices, there must be someone from the other side of the race who recognizes the problem, because a lot of times if just one race says there’s a problem, nobody is realistic about it.”

Seahawks' Michael Bennett: White player needs to join protest

The prospect of a white player and black player kneeling side-by-side during the national anthem makes sense to Richard Lapchick, a human rights activists whose work has focused on race in sport.

“There’s no question that part of the success of the civil rights movement itself was the fact that blacks and whites joined together in trying to bring about change," Lapchick said. “And getting the names of white players, be they of the Tom Brady caliber or second-string players, just any white players, would be extremely helpful in this particular case.”

There is historical precedent for such gestures and their power.

Jackson, after recently meeting with the Congressional Black Caucus, said the story of Jackie Robinson demonstrates the important role white athletes can play. In 1947, the year Robinson broke the color line and joined the Brooklyn Dodgers, the racial taunting began to subside thanks in part to a white teammate.

In response to the racial taunts, Dodgers shortstop Pee Wee Reese walked across the field and stood by Robinson at first base during one game. A statue of Reese wrapping his arm around Robinson was unveiled in 2005 to commemorate the moment.

“It was a huge moment," Jackson said, “because in some sense, when the white player embraced him, it said to the fans, ‘We must reshuffle the deck.’ ”

***

Dr. Harry Edwards, a respected social activist who has consulted with Kaepernick, said it’s important to note that white members of the Seattle Seahawks participated when the team’s players locked arms during the national anthem Sept. 11. He also said that while driving around the Bay Area, where he lives, he has been heartened to see young white kids wearing 49ers jerseys with Kaepernick’s No. 7 on them.

“We need to be honest about what that terrain really looks like,” he said, but then added that the support of Brady or prominent white quarterbacks such as Eli Manning of the New York Giants or Ben Roethlisberger would “significantly move the needle.”

Brooklyn Dodgers Pee Wee Reese and  Jackie Robinson, shown here with Preacher Roe (right) were involved in one of the most poignant on-field moments in baseball history in 1952, the year this photo was taken.

Those athletes, Edwards suggested, “could stand up and simply say, ‘We, too, oppose injustice irrespective of the target, irrespective of the victim, because that is not what America is about and that is what our national anthem really promises.’ ”

The power of Brady’s support wasn’t lost on Jocelyn Benson, head of a venture led by professional sports leagues to improve race relations. Brady was one of seven players who participated in a PSA during which the Patriots quarterback says, “Speak up.”

So why is Brady not speaking up on behalf of Kaepernick and against racism now?

“There’s many reasons why he may or may not choose another particular way of speaking out,” Benson said. “(White athletes) may disagree with the method or the particular timing of the message but are still communicating other way their support.”

NFL Week 3 kickoff times, TV info, betting lines

Green Bay Packers quarterback Aaron Rodgers drew widespread praise when he criticized a fan’s anti-Muslim comment. But when asked about Kaepernick’s protest, he told The Sporting News, “To me, the flag represents the greatest ideals of the United States of America, not the worst.”

“But different people look at different things and have different feelings about it. That’s what freedom of expression is all about.”

***

Chris Long, a defensive end for the Patriots, this week became the most vocal and prominent white NFL player to offer support for Kaepernick. Although Long said he respects the anthem and would not kneel while the anthem is played, he said he respects Kaepernick.

“I play in a league that's 70% black and my peers, guys I come to work with, guys I respect who are very socially aware and are intellectual guys,” Long said Tuesday on  ESPN Radio's Russillo & Kanell. “If they identify something that they think is worth putting their reputations on the line, creating controversy, I'm going to listen to those guys.”

Of Kaepernick’s protest, Long also said, “Listen, it's been complicated. It's brought out a lot of what we as fans and players think about the anthem, a lot of strong feelings on both sides.

“But I think we can all agree we love our vets. We love the vast majority of officers of law enforcement. But they are human beings too, and there are isolated incidents that need to be better, and I think all guys are saying is 'Listen, most people might be great cops, great people that protect our communities, but when there are injustices, let's find justice for those situations.’ ”

It remains to be seen if U.S. Soccer will take action against midfielder Megan Rapinoe for her kneeling for the national anthem in solidarity with Colin Kaepernick.

Long also addressed something that may have discouraged other players, white or black, from addressing the issue publicly.

“I've had a lot of thoughts about it, and it's hard, because you want to talk to the media, you want to say something about it,” Long said. “As you know with the media, it's a long conversation and if you talk about it for a few minutes, they might take 10-15 seconds out of your quote and take you out of context, and run with the narrative.

“But I'll make it pretty clear: I support my peers in exercising their right to protest. This is a wonderful country, and I think everyone agrees on that, but there are things in our country that can improve. I don't think that by acknowledging as a white male that America isn't the same for me, maybe, as it is for everybody, the same great place, that we're complicit in the problem or that we're saying America isn't a great place.”

Later in the week, Kaepernick said Long's stance was “huge.”

Megan Rapinoe kneels for national anthem before U.S. friendly vs. Thailand

“I don't know if he realizes how much that means to this movement and trying to get things changed,” Kaepernick told reporters. “ … Ultimately he made a decision that he wanted to talk about it. Because he's played with players whose families go through and experience this. And players who have dealt with it themselves.”

For some, that kind of solidarity conjures up memories of Peter Norman, the white Australian sprinter who in 1968 stood on the medal stand with Americans John Carlos and Tommie Smith. Norman, in an act of solidarity, wore a human rights badge when the two black Americans raised their gloved fists in a Black Power salute.

But Jackson said participation of white athletes shouldn’t be coerced.

“It’s a moral appeal,’’ he said. “People must follow their conscience.”